What to Do if Your Manager is Committing Fraud: Part 3 of 8
Part 3: Before You Report — Protect Yourself First
Discovering fraud is only the beginning of the journey. How you respond in the hours and days after your discovery will significantly affect your legal standing, your career, and your personal safety. Before you report anything to anyone, take these foundational steps.
3.1 Do Not Confront the Fraudster
This cannot be overstated: do not approach your manager, the business owner, or any colleague you suspect is involved and tell them what you've found. Doing so gives them the opportunity to destroy evidence, create a counter-narrative against you, intimidate witnesses, or accelerate the scheme. It may also put you in physical danger in extreme cases.
3.2 Do Not Alter, Move, or Destroy Evidence
Even if a document incriminates you in some minor way, tampering with evidence is a federal crime that is often treated more seriously than the underlying fraud itself. Leave everything exactly as it is. Do not delete emails, shred documents, or alter any records.
3.3 Begin Documenting Quietly
Start creating a secure record of what you've observed. This does not mean printing everything and walking out the door — that could expose you to claims of misappropriating company property. Instead:
• Keep a personal journal (on your own device, not company property) of dates, times, what you observed, and who was present.
• Note the names and locations of specific documents, file paths, or QuickBooks entries that contain anomalies.
• Write down any conversations you witnessed or were part of that seem relevant.
• Be specific: dollar amounts, account numbers, transaction dates, and names of individuals involved.
If you are entitled to access certain documents in the ordinary course of your job, and retaining copies is consistent with your role, that may be appropriate — but consult an attorney before removing anything from company systems or premises.
3.4 Consult an Attorney Before Doing Anything Else
Before you report to anyone — internally, externally, or to law enforcement — speak with an employment attorney and ideally one who also has experience in whistleblower law. This consultation is not about avoiding accountability; it's about understanding your rights so you can report effectively without inadvertently harming your own position.
A qualified attorney can help you:
• Understand whether any of your own past actions could create legal exposure.
• Determine the best reporting channel for your specific situation.
• Assess whether you qualify for whistleblower protections or financial rewards under federal law.
• Advise you on what documents you can and cannot take.
• Draft a complaint that is clear, legally sound, and protects your identity to the extent possible.
Many attorneys who specialize in whistleblower cases offer free initial consultations and work on a contingency basis, meaning you pay nothing unless they recover money on your behalf.
Have Questions? MMB MBA Can Help.
At MMB MBA, we specialize in forensic bookkeeping, QuickBooks consulting, and helping businesses untangle financial irregularities. If you suspect fraud in your organization — or if you're a business owner who suspects something is wrong — we can conduct a discreet, professional review of your books and help you understand what you're looking at.
Contact us today at www.mmbmba.com
General Informational Purpose Only
The content published in this blog post, including all text, checklists, examples, recommendations, and any other materials contained herein (collectively, the "Content"), is provided by MMB MBA solely for general informational and educational purposes. The Content is not intended to be, and should not be construed as, legal advice, accounting advice, financial advice, tax advice, investment advice, or any other form of professional advice. Reading this blog post does not create any professional relationship — including but not limited to an attorney-client relationship, accountant-client relationship, or consultant-client relationship — between you and MMB MBA or any of its principals, employees, contractors, or affiliates.